Thursday, September 1, 2011

Book Review: Legion



I just finished the seventh book in the Horus Heresy series, Legion by Dan Abnett.  Previously I'd heard a few people on different blogs & podcasts say that this book was the stinker of the series - maybe I was just ready for a change of pace, but I loved it.  I can see where some people wouldn't like it, as it has much less of the cinematic action sequences that some of the other books have, and the majority of the book doesn't show that much of the Astartes at all - what it does do much better than many of the other books, however, is show some truly three- dimensional characters.  The book is mainly centered on John Grammaticus, a powerful psyker working for The Cabal.  The Cabal is an organization that is many thousands of years old, made up of myriad different xenos races, whose ultimate goal is to defeat the powers of Chaos - it turns out that the Alpha Legion plays a pivotal role in this battle.  I won't give away the story, but I did not see the ending coming at all - it really expands the scope of the Heresy, and the choices some of the characters have to make really illustrate just how big the conflict is.  I found John Grammaticus extremely interesting, and think he's compelling enough that Abnett could easily spin the character off into a dedicated series of his own.  I also found the Alpha Legion fascinating, and would love to read another book that gave move detail about the way the operate.  Overall I enjoyed the book tremendously, and I'd have to say it's one of the standouts of the series for me so far, along with Fulgrim and The Flight of the Eisenstein.

4 comments:

  1. I was agreeing with you right up until your final line! For me, probably only the unrelentingly terrible 'Battle for the Abyss' was worse than 'Flight of the Eisenstein'. There were one or two good passages in the book that I enjoyed, but the rest - ugh!

    But aside from that; I find the stories, characters and plotting of the Heresy series (if written well enough) to be a lot more intersting than just more big battles.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Man I totally agree with you on all accounts. In the same vein I have heard that Nemesis was terrible as well but I enjoyed it. My favorites so far are Legion, Flight of the Eisenstein.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think another reason I liked Eisenstein and Legion so much is that they were both a significant change-of-pace - after the first three books, I was pretty tired of numerous retellings of the events on Davin & Isstvan III. I need to get back to the Horus Heresy series, but I ruined the screen on my e-reader, so currently I'm working on finishing the books I have in dead-tree format (right now it's the Eisenhorn trilogy...)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Could not agree more, the book was a welcome change of pace and actually had layers beyond "abaddon went stompy stompt and stabbed the man and his armour was spiky and he was bad". Legion shows that the series can be up there with the greats of modern Sci-Fi. Battle for the Abyss and Galaxy In Flames remind you that it really deserves to be on a fanfic forum.

    ReplyDelete